--- title: Intention to Make a Profit (Gewinnerzielungsabsicht) under German Tax Law description: The aim of the so-called "winning goal" is to see an entrepreneur strive to achieve a profit in the long term by means of his self-employed activity. --- [Skip to content](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/intention-to-realize-a-profit#main-content) English Show submenu for translations [Contact us](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/kb-tickets/new) ![Consultinghouse-Market-Entry-Germany (1)-1.png\]](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/Consultinghouse-Market-Entry-Germany%20(1)-1.png?height=40&name=Consultinghouse-Market-Entry-Germany%20(1)-1.png) - [Home page](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [About Us](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [Consultinghouse](https://blog.consultinghouse.eu/advisory) Open main navigation Close main navigation - [Home page](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [About Us](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [Consultinghouse](https://blog.consultinghouse.eu/advisory) - English Show submenu for translations - [Contact us](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/kb-tickets/new) - Contact us Contact us Hello. How can we help you? - There are no suggestions because the search field is empty. 1. [Help Center](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge) 2. [Taxes in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany) 3. [German Company Taxes](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-company-taxes) # Intention to Make a Profit (Gewinnerzielungsabsicht) under German Tax Law ## Under German tax law, the intention to make a profit (Gewinnerzielungsabsicht) is a fundamental requirement for an activity to be recognized as a business or self-employed activity for income tax purposes. According to established case law of the Bundesfinanzhof (BFH), a taxpayer must pursue their activity with the objective of generating a **positive total profit** (*Totalgewinn*) over the entire duration of the activity. This applies in particular to: - Commercial enterprises (*Gewerbebetrieb*) - Freelance professions (*Freiberufler*) - Agriculture and forestry (*Land- und Forstwirtschaft*) - Rental income (*Vermietung und Verpachtung* *If this profit intention cannot be established, the tax authorities may classify the activity as so-called **“Liebhaberei”** (hobby activity).* ### **When Do the Tax Authorities Doubt Profit Intention?** It is common for new businesses to incur losses in the start-up phase. Initial losses alone do not endanger tax recognition. However, problems arise when: - Losses continue over many consecutive years, - No sustainable business concept exists, - There is no realistic prospect of achieving profitability, - The taxpayer does not take measures to improve the financial situation. In such cases, the tax office will examine whether a **positive total profit forecast** (*Totalgewinnprognose*) exists. This forecast assesses whether, over the expected lifetime of the activity, total revenues will exceed total expenses. If no positive prognosis can be demonstrated, the activity may be treated as Liebhaberei. #### **Legal Consequences of Liebhaberei** If an activity is classified as Liebhaberei: - Losses may no longer be offset against other income. - Previous tax assessments may be amended. - The activity is treated as part of private life for income tax purposes. *This can result in significant tax disadvantages.* #### **Long-Term Losses Do Not Automatically Mean Liebhaberei** Longer periods of losses do not automatically lead to a reclassification. The decisive factor is whether the activity is **objectively capable** of generating profits and whether the taxpayer seriously intends to achieve them. Temporary circumstances such as: - High start-up investments, - Market fluctuations, - Economic crises, *do not automatically eliminate profit intention if there is still a realistic long-term prospect of profitability.* --- #### **How to Demonstrate Profit Intention** To avoid classification as Liebhaberei, you should: - Prepare a documented business plan - Create a profitability forecast (*Ertrags- und Totalgewinnprognose*) - Keep proper accounting records - Regularly review and adjust pricing and cost structures - Document measures taken to improve profitability - Seek advice from a qualified tax advisor (*Steuerberater*) *Active entrepreneurial behavior and documented efforts to improve earnings are key indicators of profit intention.* #### **Conclusion** Under German tax law, profit intention is an essential prerequisite for recognizing self-employed activities for tax purposes. The decisive question is whether the activity is aimed at generating a **long-term total profit** and whether this intention can be objectively substantiated. *If losses persist without a realistic prospect of improvement, the tax authorities may classify the activity as Liebhaberei. Therefore, maintaining clear documentation and a credible profit forecast is crucial to protect your tax position.*   - [Start a company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#main-content) - [German company bank account](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#german-company-bank-account) - [Shareholder structure of my new German company](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#shareholder-structure-of-my-new-german-company) - [Business registers in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#business-registers-in-germany) - [Ready made company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#ready-made-company-in-germany) - [Responsibilities of a company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/start-a-company-in-germany#responsibilities-of-a-company-in-germany) - [Company Administration](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#main-content) - [Virtual office & German company address](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#virtual-office-german-company-address) - [Liquidation of a German company](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#liquidation-of-a-german-company) - [Changing the legal type of a German company](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#changing-the-legal-type-of-a-german-company) - [German company registration numbers](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#german-company-registration-numbers) - [Parent company & Intercompany transactions](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/company-administration#parent-company-intercompany-transactions) - [Business in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/business-in-germany#main-content) - [German business etiquette](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/business-in-germany#german-business-etiquette) - [Representation office in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/business-in-germany#representation-office-in-germany) - [Self employment & Freelancing](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/business-in-germany#self-employment-freelancing) - [Employing in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#main-content) - [Employing as a foreign company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#employing-as-a-foreign-company-in-germany) - [Employing talent outside of Germany with a German Company](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#employing-talent-outside-of-germany-with-a-german-company) - [Typical employee benefits in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#typical-employee-benefits-in-germany) - [Public Health Insurance in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#public-health-insurance-in-germany) - [Digital Employment Certificate](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#digital-employment-certificate) - [Parental Leave](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#parental-leave) - [Social Insurance In Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#social-insurance-in-germany) - [Private Pension Fund](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#private-pension-fund) - [Payment of employees in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#payment-of-employees-in-germany) - [Employer cost in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#employer-cost-in-germany) - [Social security & pension](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#social-security-pension) - [Employment contracts in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#employment-contracts-in-germany) - [Minijob](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#minijob) - [Posting of employees to another country](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#posting-of-employees-to-another-country) - [Accident Insurance](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/employing-in-germany#accident-insurance) - [Accounting in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#main-content) - [German Invoices](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#german-invoices) - [German Chart of Accounts](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#german-chart-of-accounts) - [Private financial contributions](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#private-financial-contributions) - [Cash Book Accounting](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#cash-book-accounting) - [German VAT accounting](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#german-vat-accounting) - [Expense Management in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#expense-management-in-germany) - [Accounting practices](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#accounting-practices) - [One Stop Shop / Ecommerce](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#one-stop-shop-ecommerce) - [Publication of numbers & reports](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#publication-of-numbers-reports) - [Collaboration with a German accountant](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/accounting-in-germany#collaboration-with-a-german-accountant) - [Payroll in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#main-content) - [Payroll setup in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#payroll-setup-in-germany) - [Employing as a foreign company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#employing-as-a-foreign-company-in-germany) - [Payroll regulations in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#payroll-regulations-in-germany) - [Required numbers to run payroll in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#required-numbers-to-run-payroll-in-germany) - [German payroll reports](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#german-payroll-reports) - [German payroll & income tax](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#german-payroll-income-tax) - [German Payroll Tax Calendar](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#german-payroll-tax-calendar) - [Payroll Accounting changes 2023](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#payroll-accounting-changes-2023) - [Digital Sick leave report](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#digital-sick-leave-report) - [How to manage employee sick leaves in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#how-to-manage-employee-sick-leaves-in-germany) - [Government benefits & contributions](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#government-benefits-contributions) - [Payroll income taxes in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#payroll-income-taxes-in-germany) - [Car Company Benefit & 1% Rule](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#car-company-benefit-1-rule) - [Sick leave Employer Liability](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#sick-leave-employer-liability) - [Pension Insurance](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/payroll-in-germany#pension-insurance) - [Taxes in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#main-content) - [Employees in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#employees-in-germany) - [German VAT](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-vat) - [German Company Taxes](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-company-taxes) - [Company Benefits & Expenditures](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#company-benefits-expenditures) - [German Tax numbers](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-tax-numbers) - [German VAT Programs](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-vat-programs) - [German tax calendar](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-tax-calendar) - [Mergers & Acquisitions](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#mergers-acquisitions) - [German Taxes](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-taxes) - [GERMAN TAXATION OF PROPERTY](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-taxation-of-property) - [German tax return](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-tax-return) - [German customs duties and import regulations](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/taxes-in-germany#german-customs-duties-and-import-regulations) - [MyDashboard App](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#main-content) - [My Accounting Service](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#my-accounting-service) - [My Payroll Service](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#my-payroll-service) - [My Users](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#my-users) - [CFO Portal](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#cfo-portal) - [Document Management](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#document-management) - [Quick Start Guide](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/mydashboard-app#quick-start-guide) - [Data management & exchange](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/data-management-exchange#main-content) - [Accounting Data](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/data-management-exchange#accounting-data) - [Amazon & eCommerce](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/data-management-exchange#amazon-ecommerce) - [Working with Xero in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/data-management-exchange#working-with-xero-in-germany) - [Liquidate a company in Germany](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/liquidate-a-company-in-germany) - [German Company forms](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#main-content) - [The German GmbH](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-german-gmbh) - [The "Mini" GmbH](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-mini-gmbh) - [The GmbH & Co.KG](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-gmbh-co-kg) - [The Joint Stock Company](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-joint-stock-company) - [The Limited Partnership](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-limited-partnership) - [The General Partnership](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-general-partnership) - [The German branch office](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-german-branch-office) - [The German permanent establishment](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-german-permanent-establishment) - [The German representative office](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/en/knowledge/german-company-forms#the-german-representative-office) - [Home page](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [About Us](https://mein.consultinghouse.eu/de/arbeit-und-freizeit-perfekt-im-einklang) - [Consultinghouse](https://blog.consultinghouse.eu/advisory) [![Chill listening crop-3](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/hs-fs/hubfs/images/logos/Consultinghouse%20Market%20Entry%20Germany%20Logo.png?width=212&height=24&name=Consultinghouse%20Market%20Entry%20Germany%20Logo.png "Chill listening crop-3")](https://service.consultinghouse.eu/knowledge) All articles on this page are for information purposes only. Copyright © 2026, Consultinghouse